Small proof that hindsight is sometimes 20/200:

Truth be told, Swisher is a fine player and a solid addition to a White Sox lineup that needs a bat like his and an outfielder that can cover the ground he does.

We’ve beaten up on Swisher enough in these parts, so we’ll just say he had a down year. The most damning take on Swisher’s trek through the South Side requires the proper context to fully appreciate the scale of what we’ve just witnessed: Kenny Williams, in his constant three-year-long pursuit of filling the hole left by Aaron Rowand and Brian Anderson between November 2005 and May 2006, has effectively traded Ryan Sweeney, Gio Gonzalez, Faustino De Los Santos, Kanekoa Texiera and $3.5 million for an allegedly overrated pitching prospect in Jeff Marquez, a reclamation project in bust prospect Jhonny Nunez, and Wilson Betemit, the Yankees’ answer to Juan Uribe.

This doesn’t include the superfluous Griffey trade, the watched third strikes, the lame throws, the .189 on the road, the breaking up a no-hitter without getting a hit, the 8-for-51 to close the season, the 16-for-91 May, the. . . no, no, we won’t go there. That’s just plain mean.

So we’ll close the book on the Dirty Thirty with this: Swish, you were a character and (more importantly) brought more female fans to the park than anyone in recent memory, and I can’t fault you for either of those things. Enjoy New York.

Filed Under: News | Read More: , , , , , | permalink | Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.


  1. Posted November 13, 2008 at 10:02 pm | Permalink

    I was expecting a parade on 35th street today.

  2. Posted November 13, 2008 at 10:40 pm | Permalink

    Maybe over the weekend – we’ll need time to fly King Rowand in to be the Grand Marshall of the V-Swisher Day Parade.

  • The 35th Street Review. A blog about Chicago White Sox baseball. [More]

  • Archives

  • "A skeptic might suggest this season was one long victory lap, but I think it was more than that. It was a season of respect and appreciation, a lovefest. Winning changes everything, it seems, even losing."
    - Ted Cox, Chicago Reader, September 28, 2006